Learning from Ukraine (II)
Berlin arms conference brings together German drone start-up executives and Ukrainian fighters who venerate Nazi collaborators. The aim: close cooperation on advancing high-tech warfare.
BERLIN/KYIV (our own report) – At an arms conference in Berlin on Monday, representatives of German drone start-ups and military personnel from Ukrainian units that revere Nazi collaborators came together to discuss future developments in high-tech warfare and weapon systems manufacturing. The New Age Defence conference was attended by some eight-hundred people. Participants included members of brigades in the Ukrainian National Guard that openly use Waffen-SS symbols and celebrate members of the Organisation of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN), a fascist organisation of Ukrainian Nazi collaborators active preceding, during and immediately after World War Two. German arms companies are working closely with the Ukrainian military, including these ultra-right battle-hardened elements, in order to draw directly on frontline experience with weaponry. These companies are rapidly developing and upgrading their UxS products on the battlefield. UxS is the abbreviation for Unmanned Systems, with the x standing for all the diverse system categories, namely in the air (drones), on land (robots) or at sea (sea drones). The conference organisers of New Age Defence have described their objective as bringing together arms manufacturers, armed forces and policymakers, and blending Ukrainian frontline experience with German industrial know-how. What is important here is not so much the production of huge numbers of weapons as the creation of production capacities. In the event of war, these capacities can then be released to turn out the advanced military hardware needed at that stage of warfare evolution. Read more
In the pantheon of collaborators
Ukraine repatriates the remains of Nazi collaborators buried abroad. A special forces unit is to be named after mass murderers. Two Ukrainian Nazi leaders are buried in Munich. Berlin remains silent.
BERLIN/KYIV (own report) – The German government remains silent on the honours repeatedly bestowed in Kyiv upon Ukrainian Nazi collaborators and mass murderers. This silence is all the more shocking because German authorities may soon be actively facilitating further such rites. Last week, the remains of Andriy Melnyk were transferred from Luxembourg to Ukraine, where they were reburied in the presence of President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. Melnyk was the leader of the OUN(M) (Organisation of Ukrainian Nationalists-Melnyk), an organisation of Ukrainian Nazi collaborators, many of whom joined the Waffen-SS Division Galicia. Zelenskyy has recently awarded the title of “Heroes of the UPA” to a unit of the Ukrainian Special Forces. During the Second World War, the UPA (Ukrainian Insurgent Army) massacred almost 100,000 Poles and countless Jews. Outrage against this glorification was voiced in Poland and Israel, but no word of criticism came from the German government. Kyiv is now planning to establish what it calls a ‘Pantheon of Outstanding Ukrainians’. To this end it seeks to reinter further Nazi collaborators. Discussions are now underway regarding the transfer of the remains of two such infamous individuals buried in Munich. Such a move requires approval by the German authorities. Read more
Long-range drones for Ukraine
German-Ukrainian joint ventures launch production in Germany of drones that will reach 1,500 km – deep into the Russian hinterland. Moscow hints at targeting the factories.
BERLIN/KIEV/MOSCOW (our own report) – The huge expansion of drone production in Germany and other Western European countries for use by the Ukrainian military has triggered Russian threats against the sites. Several German companies announced last week new agreements to establish joint ventures with Ukrainian drone manufacturers. Among others, a German software start-up, Auterion, plans to make drones with a range of 1,000 to 1,500 kilometres at a plant near Munich in collaboration with the Ukrainian firm Airlogix. These weapons will enable strikes deep within Russian territory. Such long-distance attacks by the Ukrainian armed forces have recently inflicted severe damage on Russia – hitting for instance, key oil facilities. Airlogix’s German production site is found on a list of twenty-one companies in various European countries that document a dangerous escalation. Through their arms production they are said to be dragging their host nations “into a war with Russia”. So far it has been Ukraine, not Russia, that has conducted attacks on Russian targets in third countries – specifically on tankers in the Mediterranean. Russia could well seek to emulate this practice, likewise striking targets in third countries, including companies that facilitate attacks on its territory. Read more
‘From a position of strength’
Four years after the start of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, EU continues to make demands that block a peace settlement – against the will of a large section of the Ukrainian population.
BERLIN/KIEV (own report) – Four years after Russian tanks entered Ukraine, demands by Germany and other European states are still preventing a negotiated end to the fighting. An article jointly penned by the foreign ministers of Germany, France and Poland argues that Ukraine can only achieve a “lasting and just” peace “from a position of strength”. However, a “position of strength” is not in sight for Kiev, so if it is to be achieved the war must grind on. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz is convinced that the fighting will “only end when one of the two sides is exhausted”. In Ukraine itself, 40 per cent of the population now supports relinquishing the Donbas in exchange for Western security guarantees and a quick end to the war. The European Union, however, has been hardening its position. As a consequence, a negotiated solution looks increasingly unlikely. A recent discussion paper by EU Foreign Affairs Representative Kaja Kallas contains several demands on Moscow that would only be enforceable if Russia agreed to an almost unconditional surrender. The demand for a complete withdrawal of Russian troops from Ukraine is a case in point. Read more
Wrangle over the 28-point plan
Germany, France and the UK seek to change key elements of the 28-point ceasefire plan in Geneva talks with the US – not least to promote their arms industries.
BERLIN/WASHINGTON (own report) – Germany, France and the United Kingdom are seeking to comprehensively alter core elements of the 28-point plan for a Ukraine ceasefire at talks with the United States in Geneva. On the one hand, the European intervention is about how exactly the Russian foreign assets frozen in the EU will be used. On the other, it is about loosening any restrictions imposed on the future strength of Ukrainian armed forces. While in official statements Berlin and Brussels claim to be promoting Ukraine’s interests, what is clearly at stake are the interests of Germany and the EU. The EU plan to use frozen Russian assets to arm Ukraine would mean more weapons exports from European producers as the bloc further expands its defence industries. The 28-point plan provides, however, for the funds to be spent on economic reconstruction in Ukraine. The American plan also contains restrictions on the size and capacity of Ukrainian forces. This point is also likely to conflict with the aspirations of several European states for profitable arms exports to Kiev. If Berlin and Brussels succeed in shaping the 28-point plan to fit their demands it is expected to fail. The war would then grind on. Read more
High-risk security guarantees
The West’s ‘coalition of the willing’, including Germany, agrees ‘security guarantees’ for Ukraine, including troop deployments expressly against Russia’s will – risking yet more war.
PARIS/BERLIN/KIEV (own report) – A “coalition of the willing” consisting mainly of European states, including Germany, has agreed on “security guarantees” for Ukraine, including the non-covert deployment of NATO troops on Ukrainian territory. This was announced yesterday, Thursday, by French President Emmanuel Macron after a meeting in Paris with the participation of twenty-six countries. However, not all of them are keen to send troops. In mid-August, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz was still giving the impression that he would commit Bundeswehr forces, but he has recently struck a more cautious note. Indeed, Wolfgang Ischinger, former head of the Munich Security Conference, has called the discussion about an official Western military presence in Ukraine an “unnecessary ghost debate”. It would only make sense if Russia agreed to the plan, Ischinger argued. And Moscow has confirmed that this is certainly not the case. Russia says it will continue the war if a negotiated solution cannot be reached. Pushing in the opposite direction, NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte says the West shouldn’t care about “what Russia thinks about troops in Ukraine”. Yet NATO deliberately ignored Moscow’s red lines at the end of 2021 and the consequences are well known. Read more
Negotiations in Istanbul
The resumption of the ceasefire talks in Istanbul once again raises the question whether the war could have ended as early as 2022. Foreign Minister Wadephul warns against overestimating Russia's armed forces.
BERLIN/KIEV/MOSCOW (Own report) – Negotiations between Moscow and Kiev on ending the war in Ukraine resumed in Istanbul on Monday, with the exchange of memoranda. Their analysis would be the next step before continuing the negotiations. In the meantime, the exchange of prisoners between Russia and Ukraine is already gaining momentum. Following resumption of the Istanbul negotiations, a close examination of the ceasefire talks in Istanbul in the spring of 2022 has so far been suppressed by leading media with the categorical assertion that Russia demanded, at the time, an unacceptable capitulation from Ukraine. Detailed analyses also by Western experts prove the contrary; they again raise the question of why the West did not support or even torpedoed those peace efforts. Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul's assertion that Russia's “war machine” should not be overestimated also raises questions. The claim that Russia's armed forces will soon be strong enough to attack NATO countries serves to legitimize the current arms build-up. Read more
Obsessed with strength
Trump extends period pledged to end Ukraine war to six months. German politicians oppose a Chinese role in Ukraine reconstruction. Ceasefire brings prospect of Ukrainian ‘hatred’ towards the West.
KIEV/BERLIN (own report) - Ten days before the inauguration of future US President Donald Trump, the debate about scenarios for ending the war in Ukraine is hotting up. The Biden administration and the majority of European governments have been seeking to drag the war out, not least by supplying ever new weapons and funding Kiev. Trump, who once declared his intention to end the war straight away is now talking about needing up to six months. Meanwhile, popular support for the war is clearly on the decline, both in Ukraine itself and in Western Europe. Surveys show that there are majorities in a number of countries in favour of moving quickly to negotiations. With regard to the post-war reconstruction of Ukraine, politicians are increasingly demanding the complete expropriation of Russian central bank assets parked in Europe. Following the West’s anti-Bejing narrative, German politicians are also categorically against accepting Chinese assistance in rebuilding the ravaged economy. Beijing should “definitely not play any role in the reconstruction of Ukraine,” demands Marie-Agnes Strack-Zimmermann (FDP), Chairwoman of the Defence Committee in the European Parliament. Meanwhile, some observers expect to see elements in an exhausted post-war Ukraine develop a “hatred” towards the West as they realise NATO countries have not kept their promises to Kiev. Read more
On Europe’s shoulders
Zelensky has arrived in Brussels for talks. The key topics: shifting Ukraine support onto Europe’s shoulders, including a 40,000-strong European force to monitor a ceasefire.
BERLIN/PARIS/KIEV (own report) - Talks began yesterday, Wednesday, in Brussels on shifting Ukraine support away from the United States to the countries of Europe. The background to this scenario is US President-elect Donald Trump’s call for a swift end to the fighting between Russia and Ukraine. Trump says the burden of the war and its consequences should be borne primarily by Europe. One proposal is for the European states to provide a military force of some 40,000 soldiers for deployment in a future demilitarised zone. The buffer zone would be along the demarcation line between Ukrainian and Russian-occupied territories once a ceasefire has been concluded. The plan was discussed yesterday, 18 December, by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in talks with various politicians, including above all French President Emmanuel Macron. Macron has been advancing similar ideas for some time. Talks will continue this Thursday. Meanwhile, the Russian armed forces are advancing faster than at any time since the end of February 2022, while Ukrainian military personnel are deserting in ever greater numbers. Some estimates put the figure at more than 200,000 soldiers so far. Read more
The priorities of the West
Zelensky’s European trip to replace cancelled Ramstein summit a failure – also in Berlin. More discontent in Ukraine. Even online newspaper Politico now criticises “unquestioning” Western media.
BERLIN/KIEV (own report) – Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky returned from his trip around Western Europe, including Berlin, at the weekend without the hoped for PR success and without any real new pledges of support. Zelensky had already been duped by the American cancellation at short notice of the planned Ramstein summit. That was to be his major opportunity to promote his so-called “victory plan”. On his visits to London, Paris, Rome and Berlin Zelensky largely heard Western leaders only repeating long-standing promises. Ukraine not only finds itself increasingly on the defensive militarily, losing more and more territory; Zelensky’s government is also coming under growing pressure at home. There has been a significant rise in army desertion numbers. A sharp tax hike, which Ukrainian politicians admit is likely to be highly unpopular, has become unavoidable to help finance the war. “We will be hated,” is the prediction from President Zelensky’s party. Meanwhile, the Springer-owned online portal Politico advises in an opinion piece that a discussion of alternatives to war is long overdue. The media must face the question of the excessive burden of funding Ukraine’s war economy. Have the media, fallen into an “information trap”, “blinding us, leading us to overlook the scepticism needed when considering whether this war is winnable.” Read more
